Owner's should be wary of the winner's curse in NFL free agency. It seems that we routinely see highly-regarded players bust in free agency. See: Washington Redskins.
The reason could lie in economic theory. It's the "winner's curse," or Dan Snyder's Curse. Assume the common critique of free agency is correct and that the teams that "win" in free agency by signing the big name guy actually regularly overpay for the player on average. The reason this may be is that teams pay for a player based on their estimation of his value: some definite, but unknown dollar amount.
The problem is that even the best scouts could never precisely predict a player’s value. Some overestimate his worth, others underestimate. The team that ultimately signs a player will be the one that maintains the highest estimation of his value, which likely is a team that overestimated and, as a result, overpaid.
Of course, this doesn't universally hold true. But the greater a player's bargaining power, the less the gap between his estimated value and his actual value will be (expected profit), and the more costly an error in estimation of his value is.
Showing posts with label Economics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Economics. Show all posts
Monday, April 13, 2009
Friday, April 10, 2009
Ascertaining Greed
Self-righteous vitriol is rampant these days. Hurling "greed" at Wall Street has become a popular sport, but I submit that participation in the sport is a hopelessly hypocritical endeavor.
Isn't any income above a subsistence level inherently "greedy"? By definition, any amount beyond subsistence levels is not necessary. It only serves to further one's material interests in excessive comforts.
Moreover, the existence of a world of "rational actors" -- individuals who operate to maximize their own self-interests -- is the underlying assumption of most of public policy. What is so surprising about financiers being rational actors?
Do we really think that only a select group of businessmen maintain profit-maximizing motives (ie. greed, or "hubris" if you really want to go self-righteous, pseudo-intellectual)?
If we're ridiculing those who are greedy, the criticism should not stop at the financial sector. Doubtless, we all are regularly driven by the same motives of self-interest maximization.
Isn't any income above a subsistence level inherently "greedy"? By definition, any amount beyond subsistence levels is not necessary. It only serves to further one's material interests in excessive comforts.
Moreover, the existence of a world of "rational actors" -- individuals who operate to maximize their own self-interests -- is the underlying assumption of most of public policy. What is so surprising about financiers being rational actors?
Do we really think that only a select group of businessmen maintain profit-maximizing motives (ie. greed, or "hubris" if you really want to go self-righteous, pseudo-intellectual)?
If we're ridiculing those who are greedy, the criticism should not stop at the financial sector. Doubtless, we all are regularly driven by the same motives of self-interest maximization.
Labels:
Economics,
Greed,
Liberals,
Self-Righteousness,
Wall Street
Thursday, January 29, 2009
Conflating Stimulating the Present and Robbing the Future

Milton Friedman warned in Free to Choose, "If all we want are jobs, we can create any number--for example, have people dig holes and then fill them up again or perform other useless tasks... Our real objective is not just jobs but productive jobs." Obama and Co. have proposed an economic plan that includes spending $200 million on employing people to relay sod on the mall -- $200 million to dig holes, and fill them up again.
Labels:
Barack Obama,
Congress,
Democrats,
Economics,
Free Markets,
Labor Theory
Tuesday, January 6, 2009
Is the BCS an Antitrust Violation?

I'm from north Florida, about 45 minutes from Gainesville. My brother attends the University of Florida, and the majority of my high school friends are Gator grads. I will be in Gainesville on Thursday night with friends watching the National College Football "Championship" game between the Florida Gators and the Oklahoma Sooners. I am a devoutly loyal fan of a professional football team from north Florida, but I couldn't care less whether the Gators win or lose on Thursday.
The absence of a playoff system to determine the champion of college football completely removes all legitimacy from the sport, and I cannot devote time and emotion to something I don't believe to be legitimate. I know I'm not alone in my apprehension towards college football because of the bowl system. The collusive activity keeping the bowl system intact has restrained my consumptive interest in the sport, and the endless complaints about the system suggests that it restrains the interest of others, too.
This sparks a question: Is the existence of the bowl system to the exclusion of a an alternative, more reasonable system (read: playoff system) to determine the sport's champion a violation of antitrust law? The basic standard, if I recall correctly from undergrad, for establishing illegal anti-competitive business practices is whether the practices represent an "unreasonable restraint of trade." I've never heard an argument that could lead one to conclude that the bowl system is reasonable.
Here's hoping I get that coveted unpaid internship with the FTC this summer. I'm taking down Dartmouth Dining Services first, the BCS second.
Monday, January 5, 2009
Barney Frank, Paul Krugman, and the Apocalypse

It is a safe argument that congressional irresponsibility is a cause of the present recession. A rarer argument is that the irresponsible use of language by Democrats in congress is a cause of the recession. Accordingly, I'll fill the void and make it: the grossly inaccurate language of Democrats in politics, economics, and the media comparing the present economy to the Great Depression is a cause of the economy's problems, or at the very least stands to exacerbate them.
Consider that the short-term prosperity of the economy is foremost a function of consumption, and consumption is a function of consumer confidence and consumptive ability. Consumer confidence reached an "all-time" low in December since the Consumer Confidence Index was created in 1967. Yet consumptive ability, roughly measurable by the unemployment rate (6.7% in December), is only slightly worse than it was during the first recession of George Bush's presidency (6.3% in June 2003).
What are the determinants of consumer confidence? The economic condition of individuals is certainly a gauge consumers use, but given the disparity between consumptive ability and confidence, in this case it has clearly been overwhelmed by other barometers. It seems clear that two extraordinary conditions have primarily driven the extreme lack of confidence. The first is the erratic and dramatic behavior of the stock market during October and November. The second is the pervasive, apocalyptic language comparing the economy to the Great Depression among Democratic politicians and the media. The Dow has stabilized, but the apocalypse continues in relentless media reports.
If the nature and frequency of such reports continue, it stands to reason that consumption will be hindered by depressed confidence beyond that which it would if characterizations of the economy were accurate by Democrats and the media. The economy will suffer in the short-term as a result.
Monday, October 20, 2008
Barack Obama: Blinded by "Fairness", II

[Continued from “Blinded by Fairness, I”…]
Energy
Obama’s proposed “windfall profits” tax on oil companies would have a similar secondary effect, though more immediate and more intuitive. However, the senator’s determination to stick it to “Big Oil”, either in a grand pandering gesture to his supporters, has precluded him from heeding the wisdom arguing against such an imposition. Depending on the structure of the tax, it would at best increase the price of a gallon of gas to consumers and at worst discourage investment in alternative energy by those with the best resources to perform such research – Big Oil.
Consider if the tax were truly a tax on profits alone – that is, the government would take, say, 15 percent of Big Oil’s profits. Big Oil, like all firms, must decide whether to reinvest profits in either projects or to distribute them among shareholders. Let’s say that in the absence of this windfall, Big Oil could invest in an alternative energy project from which it expects returns of 7 percent. The alternative is to redistribute funds among shareholders who could otherwise invest in the stock market, from which, in a healthier situation, investors could expect, say, returns of 6.5 percent. Assuming equal risks of both projects, Big Oil would invest in the alternative energy.
Now, consider if Obama imposed a tax of 15 percent on total profits. The expected returns from a given project would shrink by 15 percent from 7 to below 6 percent. In such a circumstance it is most sensible for Big Oil to forego the investment in the alternative energy and to, instead, redistribute its profits to its shareholders, allowing them to invest in the stock market earning a more lucrative 6.5 percent return.
It is doubtful that even if Obama had considered or realized the adverse effects of such a tax to consumers and the environment his position would be considerably different. His Democratic base foams at the mouth at the thought of “Big Oil” and are, undoubtedly, similarly blinded by notions of fairness. Nevertheless, while it might be prudent politically that Obama adopt such policies, it is nevertheless disappointing that the candidate of “change” actually retains the same self-serving and publically costly characteristics of his peers.
Labels:
Alternative Energy,
Barack Obama,
Big Oil,
Economics,
Global Warming,
Taxes
Barack Obama: Blinded by Fairness, I

As the presidency of Barack Obama becomes increasingly imminent and as the economy continues to concern voters most, it is necessary to consider Obama’s capacity to handle complex economic issues considering he entirely lacks an academic or professional education on the mechanics and value of business whose singular motivating economic guideline is a pretense of “fairness.”
To be sure, fairness is a noble objective -- except, at the very least, when economic outcomes for all citizens are deteriorated, which Obama stunningly favors. However, like many efforts to promote economic equity, such as raises in the minimum wage, likely accompanying Obama’s proposals are plainly apparent costs tending to effectuate the opposite result. Obama’s alarming provinciality to realize the adverse effects of two of his simplest tax proposals demonstrates his inability to see beyond his subjective notion of fairness in the best interest of Americans.
Education
Obama rightly observes that the rising bill of attending college is problematic. He intends to halt this rapid upward movement by handing out $4000 to any individual who attends college and performs some form of community service. All else equal, students who performed the task would be better equipped to pay for schooling by $4000 per year. That’s hard to debate.
As it happens, however, in a monopolistically competitive market, as universities are situated, students are not the only actors. Universities determine the prices they set, and in the face of systematically greater demand, prices will naturally increase eventually entirely negating the effect of such a price increase. Assuming the supply is fixed in the time period under concern (because of requirements of a school’s charter, desired student-teacher ratios, or housing limitations, for instance) as in the diagram below, prices would ultimately increase $4000. If supply were not inelastic, the price increase would be some fraction of $4000.
Consider the situation mechanically. Let's say that the average family was willing to pay, say, $20,000 per year for college, and suppose that after hundreds of years of operations, the average university has determined that $20,000 is the appropriate price for its education. On the surface Obama’s proposed tax credit now sounds great, because college should cost the average family now only $16,000 per year as opposed to $20,000. However, since the family is willing to buy their child a college education at a cost of to $20,000, it is now willing to spend up to $24,000 to go to college. Recognizing this increased demand via increased application volumes and the well-publicized federal policy, universities desirous of renovating dorms, attracting better professors, or hosting more programs will increase their prices as much as students are willing to pay -- $24,000. Once prices adjust, the tax credit would confer no economic benefit on families, at a cost to the taxpayer of $10 billion.
To be fair, the entire price adjustment would be a “long-run” effect. That is, the price increase doubtfully would occur immediately, but, do not be fooled, in the presence of such a tax credit, prices would rise above and beyond the amount to which they would have risen in the absence of the credit. Indeed, many economists argue that much of the driving force behind the drastic increase in college tuition in the past decade, about double the rate of inflation, has been the proliferation of policies similar to Obama’s proposal.
Further consider the possibility that Obama were not reelected in 2012 and this credit were repealed. As it happens, prices are notoriously “sticky” downwards. Therefore, if the price would have risen naturally to, say, $25,000 in the absence of this tax credit in 2012 and it instead rose to $29,000, families would now have to pay $29,000 without enjoying the luxury of the $4000 credit. In such a circumstance, not only would the tax credit more rapidly effect price increases, but the ultimately represent a $4000 cost to the family.
[The second tax proposal is discussed in the next entry.]
Labels:
Barack Obama,
Economics,
Education Policy
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)